One
day in the synagogue, Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berdichev seemed to be observing a
group of his Hasidim as they prayed. When they were finished, he approached
them with a hearty greeting, "Shalom aleichem!"
They looked startled to hear their rabbi pronounce
the greeting traditionally given after returning from a long journey. "But
Rabbi," they said, "we have not been anywhere!"
The rabbi continued to shake hands with them, as
though they were travelers arriving in Berditchev. He said, "From your
faces it was obvious that your thoughts were in the grain market in Odessa or
the woolen market in Lodz. None of you were actually here while you recited the
prayers, so I was glad to welcome you back once you stopped."
This week we read: Adonai said to Avram: Get out from your
country, from your family, from your father’s house, to a land that I will show
you; And I will make of you a great nation, and I will bless you, and make your
name great, and you shall be a blessing; and I will bless those who bless you
and curse him who curses you; and in you shall all the families of the earth be
blessed.
Normally when we read these verses we tend to emphasize the
going: as if the journey was some kind of quid-pro-quo for receiving the gift
of the Land and the People; that the blessing is in response to the going. But
one commentator suggests that we look at the blessing itself more carefully,
for if we do we’ll find something else—that this is not a reward, but a
command, a mitzvah, a sacred
obligation. You and your descendants MUST live as to be a blessing.
I’m sure this week you’ve seen at least an article
describing the Pew Foundation study on Jews in North America. If not, I encourage
you to read the report itself. Most of the articles have involved the kinds of
things you’d expect: the wringing of hands and the gnashing of teeth and the
focus, as one writer for the Forward opined, about what we’re not. Apparently, according to the study,
we’re not as religious as we used to be, we’re not lighting candles anymore, or
focused on God, or affiliating. It’s as if the writers of those articles are
focused not on where we are, but again are looking forward to the boogieman of
a future without a Jewish people. But what if we focused on what we are today instead: that 94% of Jews are
proud of their Jewishness, 70% feel connected to Israel, 73% feel remembering
the Shoah is essential to their Jewish identity; and 69% feel the same about
living ethically? What would happen if we looked at Jewish living not as
something to do to get a reward of mere survival, but looked at our Jewish
experience as essential to our own living, that to be Jewish is to be compelled
to live one’s life as a blessing. Or, as Tolstoy wrote: ‘the Jew is that sacred
being who has brought down from heaven the everlasting fire, and has illumined
with it the entire world.’ What if we lived and expressed our Judaism in that
way? Would we invest in moments of greater inspiration, or persist in creating
gimmicky programs meant to bring people into the building? Would we take each
other more seriously and invest in the individual and her experience, and seek
to find ways to create meaningful community, or would we as a people continue
to pour resources into preserving institutions or events? Will we see the present
as an opportunity to invest in people seeking an authentic Jewish connection,
or will we pine for the past and agonize about the future?
Perhaps those questions aren’t fair. There’s a lot of data
to comb through, after all, and a lot of room for interpretation. But it seems
to me that we could either see this report as a source of consternation or as
an opportunity: to build relationships with individuals and Jewish community,
among individuals who are craving inspiration, to better understand the blessing
we are and live that way.
The midrash understands the words lech lecha-go—to mean “betake yourself”, meaning go forth and find
your own authentic self, be who you are meant to be. So, who are you meant to
be? What does it mean to be a blessing? How would this world be different if
you lived that way, and how can we help make that happen? We must answer these
questions for ourselves and together. Otherwise, the opportunity is lost, and the
journey will only be in our heads.
Been plowing through the text of the Pew Report this week, as the findings seem consistent with my own assessment of myself and how my attachment to Judaism has taken a number of transitions over fifty or so year. Somebody, or more accurately a lot of people, afforded me a pretty decent education which goes on to this day. But along the way, that acquired knowledge and understanding came into conflict with a fair amount of experience. A few Sacred Cows got schected for good reason. There is always elements of moving from and heading to.
ReplyDeleteThe Pew Report as I understand it seems very consistent with the two landmark books of this year, Sid Schwarz's Jewish Megatrends and Ron Wolfson's Relational Judaism which describe how Jewish life has become more personalized. Neither of these folks are really organizational Darwinists in the classic sense. Megatrends in particular includes essays largely from people who have been very much a part of the Jewish organizational system. Where they differ from the synagogues and Federations whose participation has depleted over a generation is the recognition that attachment to an organizational mission has to be earned and they go about with innovative alluring programs to do just that. Contrast this with the prototypical Federation or synagogue macher who just assumes that there must be something inferior about the individual who had an adverse experience with their organization. And while Ron and Sid and the Megatrend essayists want the organizations to adapt to the people but valuing relationships over programs, they recognize that the Jewish world is really big and they can demand no more loyalty to them than the citizens of Ur could demand of Avram.